Caribbean restaurant from Amagansett, Doubles, to take over old Plymouth Cafe space at 90 Henry St.

The popular Hamptons Caribbean counter Doubles has filed plans to take over the former Plymouth Cafe space at 90 Henry Street (at Pineapple Street) in Brooklyn Heights.
What to Expect at Doubles Brooklyn Heights
Concept: A quick-service, casual Caribbean-inspired eatery and counter.
Background: Run by the Bennett brothers, who opened their original Doubles Amagansett location in 2022 followed by a Doubles Sag Harbor outpost, this upcoming storefront marks their first permanent location in New York City.
The Space: Takes over the corner location at 90 Henry Street following the retirement of the longtime neighborhood staple Plymouth Cafe after 42 years in business.
Menu Highlights & Estimated Pricing (Based on Existing Locations)
Signature Doubles: $15.50 (Curried chickpeas on two house-made fried baras with cucumber relish, tamarind and mango chutney, green seasoning, and pepper sauce)
Roti & Bowls: Chickpea Roti ($18.00), Breakfast Roti ($17.00), and the Leilani Bowl with grilled mahi-mahi ($25.00)
Sandwiches & Burgers: Jerk Chicken Sandwich ($20.50) and Double Smash Burgers
Smoothies & Drinks: Island Blue and Strawberry Banana smoothies ($18.00)
Know a neighbor who’d like this?
Forwarding to neighbors is the best way to keep local coverage alive.
Enjoyed this read?
Get Brooklyn Heights news, openings, and events delivered weekly. No spam.
Comments
Loading comments…